Chicago Cubs vs. Milwaukee Brewers NLDS Game 1 Preview: Craig Counsell Faces Former Team in Milwaukee Showdown – October 4, 2025

Saturday, October 4th, 2025

Chicago Cubs vs. Milwaukee Brewers: NL Division Series Game 1 Preview

The long-standing rivalry between the Chicago Cubs and Milwaukee Brewers takes center stage as the two teams face off in Game 1 of the National League Division Series at American Family Field. The matchup carries extra intrigue this year, as former Brewers manager Craig Counsell now leads the Cubs into the postseason against his old team.

Craig Counsell's Unique Perspective

Craig Counsell has experienced the Brewers-Cubs rivalry from nearly every angle — as a Milwaukee native, a former Brewers player, and as the most successful manager in Brewers history. After guiding the Brewers to five playoff appearances in six seasons, Counsell made the high-profile move to manage the Cubs. With both cities just a short drive apart, the rivalry fuels excitement on and off the field. Counsell expects a lively crowd, noting that every trip to Milwaukee as the opposing manager has brought a chorus of boos from Brewers fans.

Despite his deep roots in Milwaukee, Counsell insists the focus is on advancing in the playoffs. "We're getting ready for a playoff series and trying to advance to have a chance to play in the World Series. That's the job at hand right now," he said.

Managers' Contrasting Styles

Pat Murphy, Counsell's former bench coach in Milwaukee and now the Brewers' skipper, brings a distinct approach to the job. While Counsell is known for his cerebral, calm demeanor, Murphy is blunt and expressive — a combination that has led Milwaukee to back-to-back division titles. Both managers prefer to keep the spotlight on their teams rather than themselves as the series begins.

How They Got Here

The Brewers overcame a slow start to finish with the best regular-season record in franchise history. A pivotal moment was their 8-4 victory over the Cubs on July 28, after which they never relinquished first place. The Cubs, meanwhile, edged out the San Diego Padres in the NL Wild Card Series and went 7-6 against Milwaukee during the regular season.

Who’s Pitching?

Milwaukee turns to All-Star right-hander Freddy Peralta for Game 1. Peralta has faced the Cubs four times this season, posting a 3-1 record and a 3.43 ERA in those outings, with an overall record of 17-6 and a 2.70 ERA for the year. The Cubs have yet to announce their starter, with Counsell indicating that the final decision will come after all pitchers go through their routines in the lead-up to the game.

Milwaukee Bullpen: Megill's Return

Brewers closer Trevor Megill returned from a month-long injury to pitch a clean inning in the season finale and reports feeling healthy for the postseason. During Megill's absence, Abner Uribe stepped up as closer, delivering nine consecutive scoreless appearances. Megill is ready for any role. "Let's just win some ballgames," he said.

Crowd Atmosphere: A 50-50 Split

Games between the Brewers and Cubs in Milwaukee are known for their vibrant, split crowds, often resembling a bowl game with fans from both teams making their voices heard. Outfielder Sal Frelick embraces the atmosphere, noting the energy and excitement it brings, even if the home-field advantage is diminished.

Key Matchups and Stats

Some Brewers have found notable success against the Cubs this season, with Brice Turang batting .348 (with a .902 OPS) and William Contreras hitting .298 with a .421 on-base percentage. However, Christian Yelich struggled, hitting just .170 with 19 strikeouts in 47 at-bats, while Caleb Durbin managed only a .167 average.

For the Cubs, Kyle Tucker posted a .314 average and a .467 on-base percentage against Milwaukee, while Seiya Suzuki hit just .120 with 22 strikeouts in 50 at-bats against the Brewers pitching staff.

Weather

Today at American Family Field, expect mild fall conditions with a high near 62°F and mostly cloudy skies. Winds remain light out of the northeast at 6 mph, and there’s only a 5% chance of precipitation, ensuring comfortable weather for baseball throughout the game.

In summary

The NL Division Series opens with high drama as the Chicago Cubs visit the Milwaukee Brewers at American Family Field. The Brewers’ remarkable turnaround and the Cubs’ resilience set the stage for a compelling postseason clash, heightened by Craig Counsell’s homecoming as Cubs manager. Expect a lively, divided crowd and favorable weather conditions. Key matchups on the mound and in the batter’s box could swing the momentum in this fierce rivalry, making Game 1 a can’t-miss event for baseball fans.

MLB Schedules

Today's MLB Games

There are no baseball games today.

Tomorrow's MLB Games

There are no baseball games tomorrow.

Yesterday's MLB Games

There were no baseball games yesterday.